World Library  

QR link for The Legal Status of Uncertainty : Volume 11, Issue 3 (14/03/2011)
Add to Book Shelf
Flag as Inappropriate
Email this Book

The Legal Status of Uncertainty : Volume 11, Issue 3 (14/03/2011)

By Altamura, M.

Click here to view

Book Id: WPLBN0004017775
Format Type: PDF Article :
File Size: Pages 10
Reproduction Date: 2015

Title: The Legal Status of Uncertainty : Volume 11, Issue 3 (14/03/2011)  
Author: Altamura, M.
Volume: Vol. 11, Issue 3
Language: English
Subject: Science, Natural, Hazards
Collections: Periodicals: Journal and Magazine Collection, Copernicus GmbH
Publication Date:
Publisher: Copernicus Gmbh, Göttingen, Germany
Member Page: Copernicus Publications


APA MLA Chicago

Musso, L., Miozzo, D., Ferraris, L., Siccardi, F., & Altamura, M. (2011). The Legal Status of Uncertainty : Volume 11, Issue 3 (14/03/2011). Retrieved from

Description: CIMA Research Foundation, Via A. Magliotto 2, 17100, Savona, Italy. An exponential improvement of numerical weather prediction (NWP) models was observed during the last decade (Lynch, 2008). Civil Protection (CP) systems exploited Meteo services in order to redeploy their actions towards the prediction and prevention of events rather than towards an exclusively response-oriented mechanism1.

Nevertheless, experience tells us that NWP models, even if assisted by real time observations, are far from being deterministic. Complications frequently emerge in medium to long range forecasting, which are subject to sudden modifications. On the other hand, short term forecasts, if seen through the lens of criminal trials2, are to the same extent, scarcely reliable (Molini et al., 2009).

One particular episode related with wrong forecasts, in the Italian panorama, has deeply frightened CP operators as the NWP model in force missed a meteorological adversity which, in fact, caused death and dealt severe damage in the province of Vibo Valentia (2006). This event turned into a very discussed trial, lasting over three years, and intended against whom assumed the legal position of guardianship within the CP. A first set of data is now available showing that in concomitance with the trial of Vibo Valentia the number of alerts issued raised almost three folds. We sustain the hypothesis that the beginning of the process of overcriminalization (Husak, 2008) of CPs is currently increasing the number of false alerts with the consequent effect of weakening alert perception and response by the citizenship (Brezntiz, 1984).

The common misunderstanding of such an issue, i.e. the inherent uncertainty in weather predictions, mainly by prosecutors and judges, and generally by whom deals with law and justice, is creating the basis for a defensive behaviour3 within CPs. This paper intends, thus, to analyse the social and legal relevance of uncertainty in the process of issuing meteo-hydrological alerts by CPs.


1 The Italian Civil Protection is working in this direction since 1992 (L. 225/92). An example of this effort is clearly given by the Prime Minister Decree (DPCM 20/12/2001 Linee guida relative ai piani regionali per la programmazione delle attivita' di previsione, prevenzione e lotta attiva contro gli incendi boschivi – Guidelines for regional plans for the planning of prediction, prevention and forest fires fighting activities) that, already in 2001, emphasized the most appropriate approach to pursue the preservation of forests is to promote and encourage prediction and prevention activities rather than giving priority to the emergency-phase focused on fire-fighting.

2 Supreme Court of the United States, In re Winship (No. 778), No. 778 argued: 20 January 1970, decided: 31 March 1970: Proof beyond a reasonable doubt, which is required by the Due Process Clause in criminal trials, is among the essentials of due process and fair treatment

3 In Kessler and McClellan (1996): Defensive medicine is a potentially serious social problem: if fear of liability drives health care providers to administer treatments that do not have worthwhile medical benefits, then the current liability system may generate inefficiencies much larger than the costs of compensating malpractice claimants.

The legal status of Uncertainty

Brezntiz, S.: Cry Wolf: The Psychology of False Alarms, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ, USA, February 1984.; Commission Decision 97/579/EC of 23 July 1997 setting up Scientific Committees in the field of consumer health and food safety, 1997.; De Franchis, F.: Dizionario Giuridico (Legal Dictionary), Giuffrè editore, Milano, 1996 (in Italian).; Euratom, 2007/162/EC: Council Decision of 5 March 2007 establishing a Civil Protection Financial Instrument, 2007.; Gibson, J.: Doctrinal feedback and (un)reasonable care, Virginia Law Review, 94(7), 1641–1714, November 2008.; Husak, D. N.: Overcriminalization: the limits of the criminal law, Oxford University Press, New York, 2008.; Kessler, D. and McClellan, M.: Do Doctors Practice Defensive Medicine?, Q. J. Econ., 111(2), 353–390, May 1996.; Lawson, F. H., Anton, A. E., and Neville Brown, L.: Amos and Walton's introduction to French law, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1967.; Klingman, D., Localio, A. R., Sugarman, J., Wagner, J. L., Polishuk, P. T., Wolfe, L., and Corrigan, J. A.: Measuring Defensive Medicine Using Clinical Scenario Surveys, Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 21(2), 185–217, 1996.; Lynch, P.: The origins of computer weather prediction and climate modelling, J. Comput. Phys., 227, 3431–3444, 2008.; Molini, L., Parodi, A., and Siccardi, F.: Dealing with uncertainty: an analysis of the severe weather events over Italy in 2006, Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 9, 1775–1786, doi:10.5194/nhess-9-1775-2009, 2009.; OECD: Review of the Italian National Civil Protection System, OECD Reviews of Risk Management Policies, OECD, 2010.; Olson, W.: Overdeterrence and the Problem of Comparative Risk, in: Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science, New Directions in Liability Law, 37(1), 42–53, 1988.; Stella, F.: Giustizia e modernità. La protezione dell'innocente e la tutela delle vittime (Justice and modernity. The protection of the innocent and the tutelage of the victims), Giuffrè, 2003 (in Italian).; Studdert, M. D., Mello, M., Sage, W., Desroches, C., Zapert, K., and Brennan, T.: Defensive Medicine Among High-Risk Specialist Physicians in a Volatile Malpractice Environment, J. Amer. Med. Assoc., 293(21), 2609–2617, 2005.; U.S. Census Bureau: Income, Poverty, and Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2007, August 2008.; UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction): The Structure, Role and Mandate of Civil Protection in Disaster Risk Reduction for South Eastern Europe, Geneva, 2009a.; UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction): 2009 UNISDR Terminology on Disaster Risk Reduction, Geneva, Switzerland, 2009b.; Wildavsky, A.: Searching for safety, Transaction Publishers, 1988. \section*{Court rulings}; Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee, 1 WLR 583, 1957.; Supreme Court of the United States: In re Winship (No. 778), No. 778 Argued: 20 January 1970, Decided: 31 March 1970.; Supreme Court of United States of America, 509 U.S. 579, 1993.; Tribunale di Vibo Valentia: Ufficio del Giudice per le Indagini Preliminari, Reg. Sent. 76/09, 6 September 2009 (in Italian).


Copyright © World Library Foundation. All rights reserved. eBooks from World eBook Library are sponsored by the World Library Foundation,
a 501c(4) Member's Support Non-Profit Organization, and is NOT affiliated with any governmental agency or department.